Secondly, please realise the question says star wars, not em. The original series novels published by pocket books. Star trek is a science fiction franchise created by gene roddenberry. And other galaxyshaking enigmas kindle edition by forbeck, matt. Many see star trek with its sanitized depiction of the future as inferior, while others see star wars as kids stuff with its force mysticism. Quite a lot, when you look at various books cutscenes etc. I personally think the star trek expanded universe is much more interesting then the star wars ones.
May 28, 2004 in star trek, most of the figures from the show are reasonably compatible with those from the tms not surprising, since the people who worked on the tm also worked on the show, and in star wars, most of the figures from the sw2ics are based on observations of the original trilogy from dr. If its a question of taste ie do you like star wars more than star trek, debate becomes impossible. Star wars vs star trek trailer battle for the galaxy fan. Data while supplementary elements like video games, movie box office tallies, critical acclaim, merchandising, and even music themes also add to the overall showdown tally. Since the very beginning of the star trek canon, there have been stories of practically omnipotent beings. Far out space nuts is the only one of the three series with any gilligan in it, at all. Though i think i read some of this, and the scenarios could be so silly that their having any canon validity would be bad for that reason alone. Because of the organizational elements of the federation, all of the federation planets pulling together to fight the empire with the help of the borg, romulans, etc, vs just the empire and a few bandits or rebels star trek has replicator technology that allows them to manufacture unlimited supplies, and transporter tech that allows them to beam troops anywhere instantly. While were on the subject of star wars vs star trek, we might as well discuss the potential fighting strength of each franchises strongest warriors.
Star wars or star trek, the fans have spoken infographic. For over 40 years, star trek has been a fixture in science fiction television and film. Sep 04, 2012 dive into the eternal star wars versus star trek debate with an infographic that determines which one can claim technological superiority. George lucas and jj abrams battle over the fate of star wars. Star trek lures you into a false sense of positivity that the world can be a utopia and recent events have proven it cannot. Althea is an engineer working in deep space and shes formed a deep bond with the ship she serves on, the ananke. Star trek consciously attempted to provide at least some basis however weak or novel for the science behind their. Star trek question again, i was struck not by the differences in laser strength or ship speed but by the different kinds of storytelling and world views each represents. This is as inane as superman vs goku star wars nerds will pull numbers out of their ass and technical manuals that are unrealistically high and trump all star trek numbers because whoever made them up for the manual simply said so. Rebels vs starfleet star wars vs star trek who would win. In a lot of ways, the star wars series defined what scifi is today.
Starships in startrek vs starships in starwars 58 results. If we use published specifications for star wars and star trek shields, we find that the heat dissipation of an old republic acclamator troop transport is 70 trillion gw peak 1, while the heat dissipation of a federation galaxy class starship is 3311gw peak 2. Oct 02, 2015 for starters, theres just so much more star trek to consume than star wars. Borg cube vs the death star star trek vs star wars. Jul 10, 2016 star wars era will be the start of episode 1 and star trek will be the start of the og series. Starships in startrek vs starships in starwars battles. Not only would star trek win but if gene roddenberry were brought back to life at any age, hed kick the shit out of george lucas at the same age. Michael hainsworth, firmly in the star wars camp with alan cross in the star trek corner. After star wars became an enormous and unexpected success in 1977, paramount television who had bought desilu productions with its original property star trek wondered how they could cash in on. Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading star wars vs. Well, ok, it dates back to 1977, when star wars came out. Maybe, hopefully, the wins of the hugo awards this year by n. With plenty of opinions on either side the internet often turns into a battleground on this subject.
Now, side by side, they can line up aliens, technology, story points, weaponry, and heroes from the two great science fictionfantasy stories of our age. Includes both numbered and unnumbered novels, ebooks, and various series. Star trek vs star wars difference and comparison diffen. Oct 27, 2017 many see star trek with its sanitized depiction of the future as inferior, while others see star wars as kids stuff with its force mysticism.
Even before the q, there were the organians, the metrons, the thasians, the excalbians, the list goes on and on. Trek is a voyage exploring the unknown, but star wars is fastpaced swashbuckling high adventure, with excitement at every turn disguises and daring escapes, romance, betrayal, and redemption. Download it once and read it on your kindle device, pc, phones or tablets. And on may 19, the star wars films will come to their own conclusion with the release of star wars. Everyday low prices and free delivery on eligible orders. Star trek argument ends in assault, arrest though the debate may continue forever, two men in oklahoma city allegedly took things far beyond a. For some reason i just cant get into the star wars expanded universe. Star wars wins big in weapons, starships, but star trek gains ground in planets.
Find out who would come out on top in this epic space battle on todays episode of. All your knowledge of the chronological events of the verse will be erased but your general knowledge ie glowing laser sword is called a lightsaber, will remain. This entire debate is like meaningfully debating the combat prowess of unicorns vs. Jul 10, 2015 star wars is my favorite, without a doubt, but i definitely have a love for star trek as well. Yes, theres plenty of good star wars cosplay out there, but star wars really doesnt have the decadeslong convention culture enjoyed by.
Each has a lot of spaceships, strange worlds, ray guns, and aliens, many of. I think that far out space nuts is better than both of them combined. For starters, theres just so much more star trek to consume than star wars. Arguments on both sides are strong and go back 40 years but they dont usually devolve into realworld violence. Books that perform well based on their reader engagement are published by inkitt in different formats and channels. Unless youre marvel or star wars, which, coincidentally, are owned and operated by a mega brand. Your odds of being force sensitive are the same as the galatic populace at large. Question about the firepower of star trek vs star wars. Star trek and star wars are the most influential sagas in the history of science fiction. To the casual observer, star trek and star wars look a lot alike, beyond the obvious similarity between their names. The original series is a series of novels written by various authors and based on the science fiction genre. Stripping away the atmosphere, searing the crust even a natural event like a comet collision would classify as destroying a planet. With johnny bolton, ronan barbour, sophia thomas, melissa lugo. Star trek star wars and star trek, two movie titles often confused by nonfans because the first word of both titles is star.
First we must assume that each sides weaponry is effective against each other and capable of removing shielding. The original series was released in 1966 and ran for three seasons on nbc. Dec 15, 2016 the location intelligence company looked at users who checked in to screenings of last years star wars. The novels of the series are adapted from the popular television series and movies of the same name that were telecast between the year 1966 and 1969. If its universe vs universe, star trek easily wins, every time. And other galaxyshaking enigmas forbeck, matt, bulloch jeremy, russ tim on.
To casual moviegoers, there is not much difference between star trek, the scifi franchise that launched on television in 1966, and star wars, which debuted on movie screens in. May 18, 2011 ever since princess leias starship hovered into sight on the silver screen, fans of star wars and star trek have been debating these questions. Star trek, originally a tv series, is a space western science fiction that centers around a crew who serves in starfleet, a spacebased peacekeeping and humanitarian armada. We compare the two and select a few of the best quotes the characters of these sagas left us. If you were to ask a person what movie comes to mind when you say the word scifi, star wars would likely be the answer. However, no offense to all star trek fans, but star trek bores me. The force awakens and this summers star trek beyond and then looked at. The force awakens and this summers star trek beyond and then looked at what other. Our own michael hainsworth and alan cross can often be heard defending their own camps. Even if one likes only the star wars maintream movies theres. First, star wars vs star trek normally means could the empire kick the federations ass. The location intelligence company looked at users who checked in to screenings of last years star wars.
Star wars is my favorite, without a doubt, but i definitely have a love for star trek as well. Star trek and star wars are american media franchises which present alternative scenarios of space adventure. Star trek under bantam books star trek log the animated series under ballantine. But do not be confused because the two are extremely different in all sorts of ways.
Abrams 2015 flick, that makes seven incannon movies. Star wars, originally a trilogy, is a space opera fantasy franchise set in the dis. See more ideas about star trek, trek and star wars. Kirk, captain of the starship uss enterprise, and its crew, which included spock, leonard mccoy.
An army of redshirted ensignsfrom the first star trek vs. The two franchises are dominant in this setting of storytelling and have offered various forms of media productions for decades that manage billions of dollars of intellectual property, providing employment and entertainment for billions of people around the world. At the start of the twentyfirst century, unconditional war swept across. The ananke is an extremely sophisticated military vessel, and althea feels a connection to the ship that she cant seem to muster with any of her human crewmates. George lucas admits that he was inspired to create star wars by watching star trek, among other influences. Marks, long time scifi fan who reads far too many books and watches far too much tv. From what ive seen, the federation has superior tech to the empire. Unlike star wars, star trek deals with questions of what it means to be human and portrayed a more progressive view of racial and gender roles. May 16, 2005 for the first time in 18 years, there will be no new star trek series on tv. Star wars is a fun fantasy space movie, but star trek tackles deeper questions and is true science fiction. A head to head battle with only federation ships would be interesting but unnecessary.
Bantam books was the first licensed publisher of star trek tiein fiction. As of november 2019, approximately 850 novels, short story anthologies, novelizations, and omnibus editions, have been published. And other galaxyshaking enigmas by forbeck, matt isbn. Who would win, the whole of star wars or the whole of star. Star trek, the original series first aired in september of 1969, featuring the now legendary and unforgettable, william shatner, as captain kirk. All novels were published as mass market paperback editions. Jul 07, 2017 star wars is better though 20th century fox star wars versus star trek. See also star trek adventures for the preceding bantam books tos line.
Both scifi franchises successfully created rich universes which have inspired multitudes of books, video games, toys, and tv series. I will, however, try my hand at a similar, but considerably more geeky. Star wars vs star trek in five minutes stardestroyer. Star wars measure destroy a planet in the same way that they measure destroy anything. May 04, 2017 for decades fans of star wars and star trek have debated over which one is better. Even taking away pretty much omnipotent beings like q it would be a star trek win. Star wars dystopic vision is far more realistic and prepares our. I find next to no humorous parts, and the ones that do occur is a horrible attempt at humor. Apr, 2020 star wars vs star trek pictures and artwork. Star trek was completely without a single appearance of gilligan in all 5 series 3. Beneath the with nothing left to lose, the romulan star empire engages in allout war against humanity, determined once and for all to stop the human menace from spreading across the galaxy.
Who would win in a fight between star wars and star trek. The general consensus is that star trek has more advanced weaponry, given the fact that they have shields whereas star wars ships do not. Star trek has a fiftytwo year history of tiein fiction, beginning with the 1967 publication of james blishs star trek 1. Come in to read stories and fanfics that span multiple fandoms in the startrek. Here are 19 reasons why star wars is better than star trek.
Before 2015, you could reasonably argue that star trek had gained the upper hand as a. Cold wars missing for two hundred millennia, the legendary iconians have returned, bringing with them the secret of interdimensional teleportation across vast interstellar distances. One thing i noticed even though they did character development on the big 3 hans, leia and luke they seem to be barely in a lot of the books. Star trek narrates the space exploration and interstellar adventures of james t. The use of hyperspace allowed the star wars universe to forego warp technology, so the federation has that edge. There are more, but i have some actual work to attend to, so please feel free to sound off in the comments below. There have been many sidebyside analysis of federation tech vs star wars tech.
The first star wars movie, star wars episode iv, a new hope was released in 1977. There are a few women writing trek novels, but generally speaking, scifi, including star trek, is really whitewashed. The galactic empire vs the borg star wars vs star trek who would win. Twenty chapters pit the people, places, gadgets, and such of both beloved franchises against each other. Ever since princess leias starship hove into sight on the silver screen, fans of star wars and star trek have been debating these questions. For star trek, it is highly more intelligent then star wars, and carries out a more feasible outcome.